City Water vs Well Water in Chicago (2026): What Homeowners Need to Know

When Chicago buyers and homeowners evaluate properties, one of the most overlooked decisions is: City water or well water? While most Chicago homes are on the city’s water supply, properties in suburbs or rural areas sometimes rely on private wells. Each option has distinct implications for health, cost, maintenance, and overall lifestyle. Let’s break it down clearly and locally.

Chicago’s City Water: What You’re Really Getting

Chicago gets its water primarily from Lake Michigan — one of the cleanest large natural freshwater sources in the world. The city’s Department of Water Management treats this lake’s water and distributes it through a vast municipal system to nearly 3 million residents.

Pros of Chicago City Water

• Regulated & Tested: Chicago’s water is routinely monitored and must meet or exceed EPA drinking water standards. The city publishes annual water quality reports so residents can see testing data themselves.

• Reliable Supply: You won’t need to worry about drilling, pumps, or private maintenance — just turn the tap.

• No Upfront Well Costs: Connected properties avoid the tens of thousands of dollars it costs to drill and install a private well.

Cons Residents Should Know

• Chemical Treatment & Taste: Municipal water is disinfected with chlorine and often includes fluoride — both safe but sometimes disliked for taste or odor.

• Aging Infrastructure Risks: Like many older cities, Chicago has legacy pipes, including lead service lines in hundreds of thousands of homes. Lead can leach into water, and although levels must comply with EPA rules, no amount of lead is considered truly safe.

• Contaminant Presence: Independent analyses have found multiple contaminants in Chicago water that exceed health‑based (not legal) limits, according to recent EWG data.

Tip: Even city water benefits from a good household filtration system — especially filters certified for lead if you have older plumbing.

Well Water: A Private Option for Suburbs or Rural Chicagoland Homes

Well water comes from underground aquifers accessed by drilling a well on your property. It’s unregulated by municipalities — meaning you are responsible for safety and quality.

Why Some Homeowners Prefer Well Water

• No Monthly Water Bills: Once your well is installed, you don’t pay water utility charges — a major long‑term savings.

• Natural Taste & Minerals: Well water often contains natural minerals like calcium and magnesium that many people prefer taste‑wise.

• Independence: Your water isn’t tied to city infrastructure or usage restrictions during droughts.

Important Drawbacks to Consider

• Your Responsibility: A private well isn’t regulated by the city — you must test it annually for bacteria, nitrates, and other contaminants.

• Contamination Risks: Groundwater can be affected by agricultural runoff, septic systems, and industrial activities — requiring filtration and regular testing to ensure safety.

• Upfront & Ongoing Costs: Installing a well can cost thousands of dollars, plus regular maintenance for pumps and treatment systems.

• Power Dependent: Without power — say, in a winter outage — your well pump won’t deliver water unless you have a backup system.

Health & Safety: What Chicagoans Should Watch

• Lead Pipes: Many Chicago homes still have lead service lines — a major water quality concern. Using lead‑reducing filters and flushing taps after periods of non‑use helps reduce exposure.

• Private Well Testing: If you have or are buying a property with a private well, having water tested by a certified lab is not optional — it’s critical for health.

• PFAS Awareness: The Illinois Department of Public Health (IDPH) recommends testing wells near areas where municipal water systems are impacted by PFAS (“forever chemicals”).

Which Should Chicago Homeowners Choose?

City Water Makes Sense If:

• You want turn‑key reliability

• You’re concerned about infrastructure or contamination risk

• You prefer regulated, tested water

• You’re planning to sell your home easily

Well Water Might Be Right If:

• You’re in a location with no city water service

•  You want no monthly bills long‑term

• You’re ready to take on testing and maintenance

• You enjoy natural water taste

Final Thought

Whether you choose Chicago city water or a private well, the key to peace of mind is knowledge and proactive care. Understand your source, test regularly, and consider professional filtration or treatment systems — because great water quality is essential for healthy living and smart homeownership.

Stay Connected

Ranked as a top 1% team in the Chicagoland market, Cory Tanzer and the Cory Tanzer Group specialize in the Chicago, North Shore, and Western Suburbs real estate market. With deep local market expertise and a proven track record, Cory and his team help clients buy and sell with clarity, confidence, and results.